Babywearing For All – A Harmful Rhetoric

I love the #BabywearingForAll hashtag on Instagram as much as the next person, but let’s just talk about this as a statement in practical terms for moment. Wait, whaaaaat?! Tania advocates for babywearing as a wheelchair user, she’s setting up a sling library and hopes to work supporting disabled primary caregivers. Yet, she’s question the rhetoric of babywearing for all?! Let me explain…

A side view of Tania, a white woman with short brown hair sits in her wheelchair in her back garden. She is wearing glasses with dark green lenses, a white long sleeve top, red checked pinafore dress, black leggings and brown boots. Asleep on her back in a navy and white woven wrap is Elise, her blonde and and a half year old.

… Firstly, I think it’s important to talk about what has instigated this post. There’s a whole lot of ableism to unpack in the use of the phrase ‘babywearing for all’. I won’t be able to cover all of it in this blog post. But, I’m going to try my best to tackle the key elements that stick out to me, from my experiences.

I’ve been approached a few times on Facebook and Instagram by people wanting to share one of my photos. It’s always photos showing me babywearing as a wheelchair user. Before I go any further, I feel I need to preface what I’m about to say. I know that for the majority of people, their intentions aren’t to harm or cause offence. I think most people are trying to be complimentary, it just… well… isn’t. Here’s an example (created based on comments I’ve received):

Tania, a white woman with short brown hair, sits in her wheelchair in the outside space of a restaurant. She is wearing glasses with dark green lenses, a short sleeved grey top and a long navy skirt with a pink floral pattern. On her back in a black buckle carrier is Elise, her blonde 1 year old. Elise is wearing a white top and grey trousers with no shoes on.

“Hi! I love your profile photo of you back carrying in a wheelchair. I’m in a parenting Facebook group where Mum’s make excuses that they can’t babywear because of back pain amongst other things. Could I share your photo please?”

Here’s the thing – it may well be that these mothers can’t wear their babies because of their back pain. I know, right?! Pain can stop us doing things. Who knew?! Just because I can wear Elise, doesn’t mean others with hEDS, others with unstable joints, chronic pain, etc. can wear their infants. And it’s harmful to draw this comparison. 

Ali Dover Moment review, where to buy a woven wrap,

There may be several other factors that mean these mother’s (or other caregivers – it’s not just about the Mums, people!) can’t wear their babies. Including a lack of accessible advice. I don’t want my image to be used in a post that may (unintentionally) makes others feel their pain is invalid or that they’re not doing a good job as a parent.

It may be that these caregivers don’t want to wear their babies. They may feel judged for this and use ‘back pain’ as a reason, to escape judgment. No one should feel they have to give or create a reason for a perfectly valid parenting choice. Especially when it’s no one else’s business.

Firespiral Dryad Sunset Seafoam, The Joy Of Babywearing, where to buy a woven wrap,

Parents are doing their best for their children. We need less judgment in this world, not more. I want to champion ‘accessible babywearing’ – support for all who want to wear their children, regardless of disability, gender, social class, financial situation, etc. The ‘babywearing for all’ rhetoric adds pressure to those who physically can’t babywear and those who don’t want to – both of which are valid reasons.

Now, let’s move away from the words and look at the physical – why in practice ‘babywearing for all’ isn’t achievable for some people.

Tania, a woman with tied up brown hair sits in her wheelchair in her back garden. She is wearing glasses with dark green lenses, a short sleeve white top, a knee length denim skirt and brown sandals. Wrapped to her front in a green and teal Sycha Slings Prehistoric Spring Sky woven wrap is Elise, her blonde 1 year old. Elise is wearing a pink short sleeve top and is holding a pair of sunglasses. Her yellow shoes are peeping out from the tail of the woven wrap, which is tied at Tania's shoulder. Tania is looking at Elise and smiling.

A couple of weeks ago, my pain flared. It’s the worst I’ve experienced since Elise was born. I’d had a busy few days, including a lot of public transport travel and my body had been shaken around more than it could cope with. Joint instability was high and pain was horrendous. I couldn’t wear Elise for a week, which was really tough for me.

There were several reasons that I wasn’t able to wear Elise:

  • Increased joint instability
  • Increased risk of injury
  • High pain levels
  • High levels of fatigue
  • Increased PoTS symptoms
  • Increased fall risk

Tania, a white woman with short brown hair, sits in her wheelchair in her garden. She is wearing glasses with dark green lenses, a white short sleeve top, a knee length denim skirt and black sandals. She has Elise, her blonde 1 year old on her front in a black buckle carrier with small grey stars on it.

Each one of these reasons is valid in its own right. I love babywearing. It’s an important part of my parenting journey as well as mine and Elise’s lives. However, for a week, I wasn’t well enough to do it. This isn’t me making excuses to ‘have a break’. This was me so unwell that I needed help to look after my daughter. I couldn’t dress her, couldn’t play with her and couldn’t wear her.

For many chronically ill and/or disabled parents, activities have to be managed carefully. One activity may take up more energy or cause more pain than others and as a result, parents may be forced to be selective about which activities they do. Using a pram or pushchair rather than wearing them may mean that they have more energy for reading or playing with their children.

Baby Monkey Symphony Woven Wrap, babywearing has, Things Aren't Always What They Seem, woven wrap front carries,

Yes, there are many ways to adapt babywearing/slings for disabled and chronically ill parents, but this doesn’t mean that every person can babywear. We also need to remember that not everyone has the support around them to be able to find the most suitable sling for their needs or find adjustments to make babywearing possible. We need more support for those parents and caregivers wanting to babywear, not tearing down those who can’t or don’t want to.

Hi, I’m Tania. I was too unwell to babywear, and that’s ok.

When Tania Talks Signature

Find me on:

Twitter | Instagram | Pinterest | Facebook | YouTube

You can also check out the Accessible Babywearing Facebook page!

A Pinterest pin for the Babywearing For All - A Harmful Rhetoric blog post

Tania

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.